Mike's Minute: The accuracy of polls in election year

Published: Aug. 29, 2023, 10:24 p.m.

Once again, we have an interesting insight into polling.\xa0\xa0

Yesterday we told you about the poll results from TOP and their numbers in Ilam.\xa0\xa0

Ilam is a blue seat in Christchurch. It was held for years by Gerry Brownlee until the Covid upheaval three years ago when Sarah Pallett, who never thought in a million years she would win it, won it.\xa0\xa0

Raf Manji, who is TOP's leader, did what Gareth Morgan should have done previously and is standing in a local seat with the outside chance of winning it, thus avoiding the 5% threshold of MMP, which they were never going to get to.\xa0\xa0

The reality is, despite that, they aren't going to get to it this time. If I was giving advice, I would genuinely look at how they present themselves.\xa0\xa0

I watched an interview with Raf a week or so back and was bewildered by what he was saying as regards teal visas. At the end of the interview I could not work out who they were, what they stood for and who they would align to by way of a major party.\xa0\xa0

Yesterday, according to his Raf Manji's own party's polling, which to be fair polled a seriously larger number of punters than this morning's Taxpayers Union Curia poll, was behind the National candidate Hamish Campbell. But not by much.\xa0\xa0

And the Curia poll confirms it. Or does it?\xa0\xa0

That is the problem we are starting to see already this campaign - are the polls even slightly accurate? Has polling become too hard?\xa0\xa0

Are there too many people, allegedly, undecided?\xa0\xa0

In the Taxpayers' poll Manji, who was a close second in his own poll, is a distant third in this one, behind even the Labour candidate.\xa0\xa0

If you take out the undecided's he is an even more of a distant third.\xa0\xa0

In other words, who's poll do you believe?\xa0\xa0

The margin of so-called era is out the door, out the window and it\u2019s a picture of two completely separate races.\xa0\xa0

As I say, I don\u2019t think TOP have a chance, either in Ilam or at 5%. But what they wanted from their poll is the sense they were genuine contenders.\xa0\xa0

And that is the danger of \xa0polls - who do you believe? How much do they affect the narrative and are they actually accurate, or just a vehicle for spin?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.