Mirror, mirror, on the wall, who's the guiltiest one of all? This week we're looking at season 1, episode 5, "Bloody Mary." It turns out the Bloody Mary of urban legend isn't just a legend in Toledo, Ohio--she's a ghost who's out to punish people with deadly secrets, including Sam Winchester. Find out who needs a plushie hug (or twelve), which underrated Stones song closes the episode, and why Jewish people cover mirrors while sitting Shiva in today's show.