Old Joy came up to the show and performed a magic trick – they started with three members, but left with four! Set list: “Koi Pond” “Julianna” “Good Riddance” (Green Day cover) “Rover Shore” “Chickenbone” (in a field) “Betsy” “Roots” “Phosphenes” “Pristine” (Snail Mail cover) Originally aired: December 7, 2018