Adam opens this week's episode of Reasonable Doubt asking Mark about a recent 60 Minutes segment about the extremely high homicide rate in Chicago. Then the guys talk about the New Years festivities in which Don Lemmon got drunk live on CNN while Mariah Carey had a horrendous performance on another station. After that, Adam and Mark question an seemingly inappropriate punishment for children misbehaving. Before they wrap, the guys talk about themselves and their kids getting in trouble with the police as youngsters.