Looper: Ted Chiang on causal loops, mama bears, and time travel

Published: Feb. 16, 2016, 7:42 a.m.

Ted Chiang, Guest Co-Host \n\n

Thanks to Ted for coming on and helping us figure out what\u2019s going on in Looper. Rather than an interview, Ted is a fully-fledged guest co-host with all the power that entails. :)

\n\n Plot Outline \n\n

This gets a little convoluted, because the movie is not incredibly worried about logical consistency.

\n\n Looper Isn\u2019t Actually About Loops \n\n

Despite appearances and the language in the film about loops and looping, we decide that either there are no paradoxical loops or the movie just doesn\u2019t make a lot of sense in this regard. Or maybe both things. Probably both.

\n\n Diagramming Timelnes \n\n

We straighten out how many Bruces/JGLs there have been and how they all lived out their lives. It might be more than you think! Ted has to reign us in so we don\u2019t spend the whole show making diagrams with straws. :)

\n\n \n no straws, but we spent some time with a whiteboard. too much time. here is a sampling\n\n CC-BY-NC\n\n Motherhood \n\n

Actually it turns out this movie is about motherhood (an uncommon topic for science fiction) and the importance of a mother in keeping boys from growing up \u201clost.\u201d We needed a professional writer on the show to get us to shut up about time travel long enough to figure out the point of the movie. Thanks, Ted.

\n\n Free Will \n\n

Comparing and contrasting the appearance/reality of free will in this film and other examples (Twelve Monkies, Back to the Future).

\n\n Rewriting Looper \n\n

Ted tries to rewrite the movie but realizes how important all of the logically difficult plot devices are to the story and characters.

\n\n

_The first half of the film, where criminal organizations are sending people back in time to be killed - that made no sense at all! And that really bugged me.

\n\n

But I quite liked the second half of the film, which was about the importance of motherhood and the possibility of breaking the cycle of violence.

\n\n

I wanted there to be a way to fix the first half of the film, but keep the second half.

\n\n

So I, in my mind, tried to rewrite the film\u2026_\n-Ted Chiang

\n\n

And keep an eye out for the upcoming movie \u201cArrival\u201d based on Ted\u2019s story \u201cStory of Your Life\u201d (with Jeremy Renner and Amy Adams) probably some time this year. Should be really good!

\n\n\n\t
    \n\t\t\n\t\t\t
  1. \n\t\t\t\tStories of Your Life and Others by Ted Chiang: iTunesAmazon\n\t\t\t
  2. \n\t\t\n\t\t\t
  3. \n\t\t\t\tThere is No Loop in Looper by Prof Hames Van Cleve: A Time Travel Website\n\t\t\t
  4. \n\t\t\n\t\t\t
  5. \n\t\t\t\tDirector Rian Johnson Talks Plot Holes and Burning Questions: YouTube\n\t\t\t
  6. \n\t\t\n\t
\n\nSupport the show!